WPP PROCUREMENT DICTIONARY™

Moderation

A controlled process in which evaluators review scoring differences and agree or confirm the final evaluation outcome in accordance with the published method.

EvaluationIntermediate2 min readReviewed July 2026
30-second answer

Moderation is the controlled evaluation stage in which scorers review evidence, discuss differences and reach or confirm the final score in line with the published methodology.

Detailed explanation

Evaluators may first assess responses independently and record provisional scores with evidence-based reasons. Moderation then provides a structured forum to examine differences, test the written evidence and determine the score supported by the submission.

The purpose is not to average opinions or reward persuasive personalities. The discussion should remain anchored to the published criteria, descriptors and content of the tender. A strong audit trail explains why the agreed score is justified.

Suppliers cannot control moderation, but they can write responses that survive it. Clear headings, traceable evidence, quantified commitments and direct alignment to the question make it easier for evaluators to defend higher scores.

Why it matters

It supports consistency and a defensible audit trail.

How buyers use it

The buyer uses moderation to promote consistency, resolve scoring differences and create a defensible final evaluation record.

What suppliers should do

  1. Write only against published criteria.
  2. Make evidence easy to locate and verify.
  3. Use precise commitments rather than ambiguous language.
  4. Check consistency across answers and attachments.
  5. Have an independent reviewer challenge the score before submission.

Where it fits in the process

  1. 1Independent evaluation completed
  2. 2Score differences identified
  3. 3Evidence discussed against descriptors
  4. 4Final score and rationale agreed
  5. 5Audit record completed

Frequently asked questions

Are evaluator scores simply averaged?

Not always. The published methodology determines whether scores are moderated, averaged or otherwise finalised.

Can moderators add information not in the tender?

Evaluation should be based on the submitted evidence and any permitted clarification or verification.

Why do evaluators score differently?

They may interpret evidence or descriptors differently, which is why structured moderation is valuable.

Can suppliers attend moderation?

No. It is an internal evaluation process.

How can a supplier prepare for moderation?

Use an internal mock moderation in which reviewers justify scores from the written response alone.

Did this explanation help?Your feedback helps us improve the dictionary.
EmailShare on LinkedIn